Best Crib Mattress Pads for Newborns – Safe, Soft & Waterproof

You know how messy things can get in the crib, so you need the right protection and make sure you will not ruin the expensive mattress soon before setting in up. The quality crib mattress pads can help you keep your baby’s mattress clean and fresh, making the crib more comfortable.

To save you the hassle of spending hours researching, we have gathered our 6 top picks when it comes to mattress pads for cribs. Keep on scrolling down to find the right one for your baby.

Related Post: Best Crib Tent To Keep Cats Out Of Crib & Pack N Play

Margaux & May 2 Pack Ultra Soft Crib Mattress Protector

This crib mattress pad has passed all the tests when it comes to durability and reliability. It is breathable, waterproof, and you can easily wash it and keep it clean and fresh. Moreover, there are two mattress pads in the pack, so you will have one spare to have on hand.

You can be sure it will not be destroyed with washing or drying because the manufacturer used reinforced threads and protected waterproof lining. These make the pad long-lasting and durable.

The cover is extra soft and quiet and provides a luxurious feeling, so you don’t have to use a sheet over it. All of the materials used are hypoallergenic, so your baby’s sensitive skin will not be hurt.

The first layer is made from bamboo rayon for superior softness, while the second one provides the perfect balance of absorption and comfort. The third and fourth layers are responsible for the heat and water resistance. The manufacturer offers a full lifetime warranty with no questions asked.

View on Amazon

• Size: 28 x 52 x 9 inches
• Waterproof, breathable, and soft
• Machine washable and dryable

Carters Quilted Crib Protective Mattress Pad

This crib mattress pad promises to keep all the little accidents under control. It is made from a soft polyester to provide your baby with support and cushioning. It is not too tight, so it can be quickly and easily removed when you need to clean it up.

This mattress pad for the crib is machine-washable; it can be effortlessly kept clean and fresh. It is recommended to wash and dry it at low temperatures, though.

It is hard not to mention the snow-white color – it is one of the top choices for mattress pads. This one will also fit any standard crib with a size 52 x 28 inches, and it will lay flat on the mattress. This is the greatest waterproof mattress protector for cribs available on the market nowadays, so give it a try.

View on Amazon

• Size: 11 x 9 x 1.3 inches
• Waterproof
• Designed from soft polyester

Newton Baby Waterproof Crib Mattress Pad Protector

This crib mattress pad was designed to provide your baby with the finest sleeping experience and protect the crib’s mattress at the same time. The cover is made from superior materials that offer optimal increased air circulation and decrease the risk of suffocation while your little one rolls over. They also keep the pad cool to avoid overheating during the night.

The TPU layer makes this the pad waterproof and moisture absorbing while keeping it breathable at the same time. The skirt has mitered corners, which ensure it will tightly fit any standard-sized crib mattress. It is a fact that if your infant sleeps well – you will sleep well. And this waterproof crib mattress pad can make this happen.

View on Amazon

• Size: 17.3 x 4 x 11 inches
• Hypoallergenic and protects against dust mites
• Machine washable and dryer friendly

PlushDeluxe Crib Mattress Protector

This waterproof mattress pad for a crib is made from breathable bamboo fabric and performs excellent at absorbing and wiping away moisture. This cover is so smooth and soft that it allows your baby to sleep on it without sheets. It is also noiseless, so you will not be waking up every time your infant rolls over.

You can rest assured that your baby can sleep peacefully, as the pad is absolutely free of latex, BPA, phthalate, vinyl, and any other harmful chemicals. It is machine washable and dryer friendly, but still, it is best to choose a gentle program with lower temperatures. The elastic band ensures that the crib mattress pad will stay in place and will not slip or bunch up. Your baby’s mattress will be completely covered and safe from the top, bottom, and sides.

View on Amazon

• Size: 9 x 10 x 2.36 inches
• Bamboo fabric, harmful materials-free
• Waterproof, noiseless, and soft

Newton Baby Crib Mattress 

This is another excellent choice coming from Newton Baby. This waterproof crib mattress pad does not compromise durability or performance. The Wovenaire technology core features a 2-stage cover, which ensures it will last for a long while your little friend is growing. The two layers achieve the perfect balance between superior comfort and super absorbing and waterproof properties.

Plus, they ensure optimal airflow and breathability and reduce the suffocation risk while your child rolls over. This pad could be perfect for both infants and toddlers, and you can easily keep it fresh and clean as it is machine-washable. The pad is also Green Guard Gold Certified for the lowest emissions.

View on Amazon

• Waterproof and breathable
• 2-stage layered
• Durable and long-lasting

Sealy Waterproof Crib Mattress Cover

This waterproof mattress crib cover can be the perfect solution if things get messy around the baby’s room. It has excellent absorbing abilities, and it comes in a set of 2 – you can always have one spare for the moments where the other is in the washing machine. The crib mattress cover has a waterproof barrier for protection from spills and moisture. And all the materials used are PVC, BPA, and Latex-free.

The quilted knit top and hypoallergenic quilted filling will provide the right level of softness, comfort, and cushioning that your baby needs for a good night’s sleep. This pad will securely fit the mattress without slipping off or shifting, thanks to the SecureStay full stretch skirt featured. Of course, the pad is machine-washable as well, to keep things clean and fresh. It can fit USA full-size standard crib with 52 x 28 inches size.

View on Amazon

• Size: 52 x 28 x 0.5 inches
• Pack of 2 pads
• Meets the CHCC regulations

When it comes to your baby, you should never settle for anything but the best. This is why when things get messy, you need to have them under control. The right crib mattress pads will do the work for you. But finding the right mattress pad requires in-depth research and considering some essential things.

• First, your pad must be waterproof. This is the main reason why you are looking for a protector pad – to keep the mattress dry and clean. We all know how things can get messy around babies, so trust me; you need a waterproof protector pad.
• Get a pad for the mattress that can be washed in a washing machine – this will save you a lot of time and, honestly, make your life easier.
• Your baby’s skin is sensitive and delicate, so always choose a waterproof crib mattress cover that is hypoallergenic and is free from harmful content.
• You will still need to choose a model that is soft and cushioning enough to provide your child with the proper lever of cushioning and comfort.

Related Post: Best Sheets for Graco Pack 'n Play: Top Picks for Comfort & Fit

Finding the best crib mattress pad isn’t just about comfort — it’s about keeping your baby’s sleep space safe, clean, and healthy. With so many options available, knowing what to look for can make your purchase faster and more confident. Here are a few essential factors to consider before buying:

Material and Comfort

Your baby’s skin is extremely delicate, so you’ll want a mattress pad made from soft, breathable, and hypoallergenic materials such as cotton, bamboo rayon, or microfiber. These fabrics allow airflow and prevent overheating during sleep. A plush surface will also add a gentle layer of comfort without compromising the firmness of the crib mattress — which is crucial for infant safety.

Waterproof Protection

Accidents happen — and a waterproof crib mattress protector is your first line of defense. Look for a pad with a non-toxic, vinyl-free waterproof barrier to prevent liquids, spit-up, and diaper leaks from soaking through. A good waterproof layer will protect your investment and keep the crib clean and odor-free.

Fit and Elastic Edges

Always double-check the size of your crib mattress pad. The best crib mattress pads have deep pockets and strong elastic edges that hold the pad securely in place, even as your baby moves during sleep. A snug fit is important for both safety and comfort — loose fabric can pose a suffocation risk.

Ease of Cleaning

Parents already have enough laundry to deal with, so choose a machine-washable and dryer-friendly mattress pad. Durability matters — make sure the pad can withstand frequent washing without losing its waterproofing or softness. Having a 2-pack set is a smart choice, so you always have a spare one ready when needed.

Safety Certifications

Always check if the crib mattress pad is certified by OEKO-TEX® or GREENGUARD Gold, meaning it’s free from harmful chemicals and safe for your baby. These certifications offer peace of mind that your little one is sleeping on a non-toxic and eco-friendly surface.

Extra Features to Consider

Noise-free design: Some waterproof pads make a crinkly sound. Choose one labeled “quiet” or “noiseless” for better sleep quality.

Temperature control: Look for breathable layers or cooling fabrics if your baby tends to sweat.

Warranty and brand reputation: A lifetime warranty or satisfaction guarantee shows the manufacturer stands behind the product.

Related: Best Toddler Pillows: Top Picks for Safe and Comfortable Sleep

Now, when you have gone through our guide, we hope you can decide which will be the perfect mattress pad for your infant’s crib. You can rest assure that the right model will provide them with nights full of peaceful sleep, and they will be ready to face the new day.