By Ivanko80/ Shutterstock

US Doctors Blast Belgium Doctors Over Their Criticism Of Vegan Diet

by | May 30, 2019

A legal opinion published on The Royal Academy of Medicine of Belgium claimed veganism is ‘unsuitable’ for fetuses, children, pregnant and lactating woman, and teenagers among other allegations. But the US doctors have blasted the allegation by the Belgian doctors who recited the long discredited myths associated with veganism. Know more here.

US Doctors Blasts Belgium Doctors Over Their Criticism Of Vegan Diet
Photo by freestocks.org on Unsplash
US Doctors Blasts Belgium Doctors Over Their Criticism Of Vegan Diet

You might also like:

US Doctors Blasts Belgium Doctors Over Their Criticism Of Vegan Diet

According to the Belgian doctors, who’ve filed the legal opinion in the medical journal, subjecting children to a vegan diet is ‘unethical’. According to them, a vegan diet doesn’t have animal protein and the vital amino acids needed to promote healthy growth and prevent health problems in children, the Telegraph reports. This is one of the many claims they made.

Countering the claim, recently, a group of doctors from the Physician’s Committee which is a non-profit group made of more than 12,000 doctors (and authors of the Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics ) has written to the Belgian doctors denoting their key statements and conclusions were ‘misleading and erroneous,’ and not based on scientific evidence, according to a statement.

The American response cites studies from the world’s largest organization of food and nutrition professionals, which mentions that a vegan diet is healthy and ‘appropriate’ at every stage of life including pregnancy, lactation, infancy, childhood and so on. It states that a vegan diet “satisfy the nutrient needs and promote normal growth at all stages of the life cycle.”

According to the Belgium doctors’ opinion, a vegan diet is only safe for growing children as long as they are accompanied by ‘vitamin supplements,’ regular blood tests’ and medical supervision. However, Susan Levin, M.S., R.D. from the Physicians Committee noted that the Belgian academy’s misinformed conclusions could discourage people from using a plant-based diet to stay healthy. The doctor continued saying-

“Studies show that those eating vegan diets get more than enough protein, calcium, iron, and other nutrients. At the same time, just three percent of young Flemish adults are meeting daily recommendations for vegetables.

“Belgians across all age groups also fall short on fiber—an important nutrient found only in plants that can help control weight, lower cholesterol, and even prevent cancer. Health authorities should be encouraging more plant-based foods—not less.”

Susan Levin via pcrm.org

A Well-Planned Vegan Diet is “Perfect” for Children and Babies

Before the American doctors’ response to the ‘misleading and erroneous’ claim, animal rights organization, PETA responded to the criticism of vegan diet and mentioned

“What a load of ignorant codswallop!

“Kids, including my own, thrive on a balanced vegan diet, but as with any dietary regime, it’s the parent’s responsibility to ensure their child is getting all the necessary nutrients. And yes, that’s easier to achieve on a vibrant vegan diet rich in whole grains, vegetables, and pulses.”

Dawn Carr of PETA via telegraph.co.uk

Children can Absolutely Thrive on a Vegan Diet

By Helga Wigandt/ Shutterstock
US Doctors Blasts Belgium Doctors Over Their Criticism Of Vegan Diet

It is not new information that kids thrive on a vegan diet. The American Dietic Association states that “An evidence-based review showed that vegetarian diets can be nutritionally adequate in pregnancy and result in positive maternal and infant health outcomes,” adding that “a vegetarian diet is associated with a lower risk of death from ischemic heart disease.”

The recent American response to the Belgian academy’s claim duly noted if any nutrient is not reliably obtained via a vegan diet pattern it would be vitamin B12, they noted, adding the same is made by neither plants nor animals, but by bacterias. The same can be easily obtained by supplements.

For tips read our smart parent’s guide to raising vegan kids.

As long as the right balance of nutrients is delivered, a vegan diet is for sure one of the best choices. “To deny children a healthier path is indefensible,” President of Physician’s Committee Neal Barnard, M.D. noted. What do you think about the Belgium Doctor’s comment on veganism? Let me know your thoughts in the comments.

Get Raise Vegan Magazine for $29.40 for Six Months!
GET MY ISSUES 
Debayan Paul

Digital Writer | West Bengal, India | [email protected]

instagram

Comments

One Response to “US Doctors Blast Belgium Doctors Over Their Criticism Of Vegan Diet”

  1. Sally Pacholok, RN
    May 30th, 2019 @ 2:04 pm

    Belgian doctors are correct, US doctors are wrong! US doctors are ignorant to the consequences & dangers of low B12 or B12 deficiency to a growing fetus & infant.
    There is no B12 Awareness in the U.S. Physicians, nurses, & healthcare facilities need to be reeducated.
    Could it be B12? An epidemic of misdiagnoses. (2005) (2011 2nd Ed.)
    Could it be B12?—Pediatric Edition. What every parent needs to know. (2015)

Leave a Comment